Should you hire your integration lead internally or externally?

Adapted from PMI Mastery: Ensuring Deal Value

Branka Dessens and Richard Parry

For most non-serial acquirers, an external integration lead is not an unusual addition to the team. Internal teams, on the other hand, often have a conflict of interest, because by definition they represent the buying company.

The trade-offs

Trade-offInternal integration leadExternal integration lead
AdvantagesFamiliar with the company cultureUnbiased outsider perspective
Known management style and strengthsSpecialised M&A expertise
Long-term commitmentFlexible engagement (typically 6 to 9 months) and a scalable team
Singular focus; a trusted C-suite advisor
DisadvantagesPotential bias from existing relationshipsRamp-up time to learn the company
Limited external experienceHigher hourly cost, for higher value
Resources stretched, focus diluted
More subject to internal politics

Which fits your deal

An internal lead suits a strong, experienced leader already in the business; straightforward or less complex integrations; and buy-and-build strategies that need permanent, dedicated leadership.

An external lead suits complex or high-stakes integrations; turning around a failed integration; a need for specialist expertise and neutrality; stretched internal resources; aggressive buy-and-build; and infrequent or one-off acquisitions.

The CEO is ultimately responsible for overseeing and harmonizing all stakeholder interests. Their main focus naturally centers on running the business effectively. That's why engaging an external PMI lead often proves beneficial: they serve as an impartial facilitator, helping to bridge gaps and align priorities. It's somewhat like marriage counseling, where an outside perspective helps both sides communicate better and find common ground.

Branka Dessens, Partner

Often, it is both, in sequence

There are two groups of acquirers. Companies with an aggressive buy-and-build strategy often start with an external PMI manager, but then will hire someone internally. As external, we usually guide them in setting up the methodology and the playbook once you did two or three integrations together. With companies that rarely acquire, I will often run the complete program for half a year and then look for someone internally to take it over.

Branka Dessens, Partner

If you're a PE or you're doing a few acquisitions for a few years, you're better off with an external experienced consultant. I think that's better for both sides. There's a defined amount of time you'll be there, and the company gets the maximum value.

Richard Parry, Partner

More insights

Where buyout value really comes from

Richard Parry

33 public leveraged buyouts, rebuilt from their own filings. In most of them, the value came from what the business did, not from the deal structure. What that means for the work after close.

Read more

Your team already has AI. Your programme doesn't.

Richard Parry

Most clients now give their people an AI assistant and shared drives. Why that makes each person faster but leaves the programme where it was, and what a system of work adds.

Read more

Have a deal in mind?

Tell us about the transaction and the timetable. A partner will come back to you, not a sales team.

Where to find us

Atlantic M&A Partners

  • Boston, MA
  • London, UK
  • Rijswijk, Netherlands
  • Bonn, Germany